2012 ballot for Jeff McCloud
Best Picture
- Holy Motors 20
- Almayer's Folly 15
- The Comedy 15
- Tabu 15
- Beloved 10
- The Color Wheel 5
- Goodbye First Love 5
- The Master 5
- Moonrise Kingdom 5
- The Turin Horse 5
Best Director
- Leos Carax, Holy Motors 30
- Chantal Akerman, Almayer's Folly 20
- Christoph Honoré, Beloved 10
- Béla Tarr, The Turin Horse 10
- Philippe Garrel, A Burning Hot Summer 5
- Mia Hansen-Løve, Goodbye First Love 5
- Steven Soderbergh, Haywire 5
- Paul Thomas Anderson, The Master 5
- Wes Anderson, Moonrise Kingdom 5
- Miguel Gomes, Tabu 5
Best Actress
- Chiara Mastroianni, Beloved 20
- Carlen Altman, The Color Wheel 10
- Monica Bellucci, A Burning Hot Summer 10
- Gina Carano, Haywire 10
- Marion Cotillard, Rust and Bone 10
- Lola Créton, Goodbye First Love 10
- Catherine Deneuve, Beloved 10
- Kara Hayward, Moonrise Kingdom 10
- Greta Gerwig, Damsels in Distress 5
- Stephanie Sigman, Miss Bala 5
Best Actor
- Tim Heidecker, The Comedy 30
- Denis Lavant, Holy Motors 25
- Joaquin Phoenix, The Master 10
- Willem Dafoe, 4:44 Last Day on Earth 5
- Louis Garrel, A Burning Hot Summer 5
- Jason Patric, Keyhole 5
- Guy Pearce, Lockout 5
- Alex Ross Perry, The Color Wheel 5
- Matthias Schoenaerts, Rust and Bone 5
- Seann William Scott, Goon 5
Best Supporting Actor
- Matthew McConaughey, Magic Mike 25
- Michael Shannon, Premium Rush 20
- Paul Schneider, Beloved 15
- Udo Kier, Keyhole 10
- Antonio Banderas, Haywire 5
- Milos Forman, Beloved 5
- Louis Garrel, Beloved 5
- Tom Hardy, Lawless 5
- Mark Ruffalo, Marvel's The Avengers 5
- Bruce Willis, Moonrise Kingdom 5
Best Supporting Actress
- Kate Lyn Sheil, The Comedy 20
- Karen Maruyama, The Campaign 15
- Salma Hayek, Americano 10
- Alison Pill, Goon 10
- Isabella Rossellini, Keyhole 10
- Ludivine Sagnier, Beloved 10
- Céline Sallette, A Burning Hot Summer 10
- Emily Blunt, Your Sister's Sister 5
- Megalyn Echikunwoke, Damsels in Distress 5
- Scarlett Johansson, Marvel's The Avengers 5
Best Screenplay
- Leos Carax, Holy Motors 25
- Carlen Altman and Alex Ross Perry, The Color Wheel 20
- Miguel Gomes and Mariana Ricardo, Tabu 15
- Christoph Honoré, Beloved 10
- Whit Stillman, Damsels in Distress 5
- Hong Sang-soo, The Day He Arrives 5
- Quentin Tarantino, Django Unchained 5
- Mia Hansen-Løve, Goodbye First Love 5
- Lem Dobbs, Haywire 5
- Paul Thomas Anderson, The Master 5
Best Scene
- , Magic Mike 30
- , The Comedy 15
- , Holy Motors 15
- , Almayer's Folly 10
- , A Burning Hot Summer 5
- , Holy Motors 5
- , Americano 5
- , Looper 5
- , The Turin Horse 5
- , Rust and Bone 5
Top Ten List
- Holy Motors
- The Comedy
- Tabu
- The Color Wheel
- Almayer's Folly
- Goodbye First Love
- Moonrise Kingdom
- The Turin Horse
- The Master
- Beloved